Angie McMahon
Keller Williams Southern Arizona

What they say about us ...

"Angie was great. She explained each process of the transaction and quickly responded back to any questions we had. Kept us informed at all times. She truly knows the market and the local area. I highly recommend her."

—Jennifer Routhier


"Extremely professional and knowledgeable about the area. She is very helpful! Highly recommend Angie McMahon, she's a true blessing to the real estate industry and to the White Mountains!"

—Alexandra Musser


"Pinetop is a GORGEOUS place, so let the absolute PROS at Pinetop Properties make your buying experience amazing!! They are the BEST!!!!!!!!"

-Melanie Lane


"Angie McMahon was outstanding, friendly, easy to communicate with and DELIVERED like a PRO!"

-Sterling Smith


"I love this Real Estate pro! I highly recommend Angie! She is a consummate professional!! Call her!"

-Tony Hughes


"Angie, thanks so much for the fine job you did during the buying experience in Show Low. You showed me your knowledge and expertise as a realtor. You always found a solution to the hurdles of a home purchase. I got lucky when I was referred to you. Thanks again for everything." 

—Mike Cartner - Home Buyer


Angie guided us through the purchase of a home. Due to several factors we did almost all of the transaction via email and FedEx. The process from start to finish was quick, efficient and thorough. We started with email updates of homes available in our price range and area. We were able to rule out some by just researching the information she provided online. We would highly recommend Angie to any prospective home buyer or seller. Her professionalism and dedication to making the process effortless is commendable. Angie has our highest marks for all her effort. She truly went above and beyond in her service to us.

—Gary & Lenora


I was extremely pleased with Angie and her team. I felt as if my property and needs mattered, which was initially a concern as my home had to be a short sale. Angie and the rest of the team were very responsive, she would answer my calls 99% of the time and if she couldn't answer when I called she always called me right back. She was on top of everything, and kept trying when I wanted to just give up, she was a positive person during a frustrating situation. I would highly recommend Angie and this office.

—Tara Meyer


Best agent I know. She sold my house in record time. I changed Brokers and Companies after 7 months
on the market. Angie had the house sold within 2 months from start to finish.

—Jay Casey


Listed & sold home in tough market. She researched, advised, never, ever gave up & went above & beyond time & again. We had to relocate across country & Angie managed the sale with us 2000 miles away. She kept us informed every step of the way. If we ever return to the area, Angie will be at the top of our list to assist in finding a new home.

—Darrell and Balerie Cunningham


Angie helped us to work through a difficult purchase where title concerns threatened to stop the transaction and needed several months to correct. The house we ended up purchasing needed several title related particulars worked through before we could move in; and, Angie assured us along the way that
we needed to be thorough to protect ourselves in the deal. Her expertise with private wells, easements, rural property, lot access, county requirements, developed lots vs undeveloped, etc. was vital to our success in a happy purchase. Angie was very professional, a good communicator, and conducted herself
with integrity. Angie also worked very smoothly with her office staff and partners and together make a team that is hard to beat.



Angie was recommended to me by a friend and asking her to handle the sale of our home turned out to be the best decision I have made in a decade. Angie listens carefully to what is important to the client, and works on her side to do everything possible to satisfy those needs. Because of her diligence, her continual effort, her knowledge of the real estate market, and the marketing expertise used at Keller Williams we were able to sell our home at full asking price quickly after the initial listing.

—L. Worthey


Angie came highly recommended to us by a local Title/Trust professional and exceeded our expectations. My wife and I were looking for something very particular and Angie never showed us a listing that wasn't a potential fit. Her background gave us confidence when looking at 'fixer-uppers' and her market knowledge gave us confidence in what value we were really looking at in finished homes. We are so thankful to have been connected with Angie and we would hope that this review gives others the same direction. The house we ended up purchasing needed work before we could move in; and, Angie assured us that she would protect our interest throughout the deal. We ended up using Angie to sell our existing home along the process, even though that wasn't our original plan, due to the extraordinary comfort we had in working with her. It was on the market four 4 or so weeks and timed perfectly to coordinate the move between the old and new house. Angie was extremely helpful in this aspect to align our expectations with the market conditions and we honestly feel that our final selling price was very competitive with other homes in the area. As a side note, we were selling in a different area than where we bought and Angie was proficient in both areas of the market. Angie was very professional, a good communicator, kind and patient. Finding people today that have integrity, are honest, and are very capable in what they do is rare today.

—Clint Haas


I had the pleasure of meeting Angie McMahon at an open house. I walked into a large house that needed a lot of repairs. I said, “ I wish you luck selling this house!” Angie listened to my negative comments (what a mess, look at the work, this will cost a fortune to fix up) and then told me that you never know where somebody is at in their life. She stated, “What is considered work for one person can be an exciting adventure to another.” She was right! There was a time in my life when I would have viewed fixing any house up as fun and now it would be considered work. I knew at that moment there was something different about this agent. She is not closed-minded and has the ability to work with any social class. Prior to this, I spent three months searching for a home with another agent. Although, I had an accepted contract on several homes... none made it through the inspection period. I was exhausted and began searching on my own. I had contacted several new agents but I had not made a decision yet.... Angie stepped up to the challenge and set out to find us (my daughters and me) a home. We located a home the next day, which did make it through the inspection period. Angie had a list of professional people to take care of whatever surfaced.

Thank you Angie for being such a hard worker and using your Real Estate knowledge to protect our best

—Debbie Marshall


Hi! I just wanted to thank you for all your help in selling our home. From the very beginning, you made Mark and I feel so comfortable with your professionalism and your promptness! As you know, we had some bad experiences with Realtors in the past, and you changed our way of thinking in only 3 weeks!! You were direct and honest and you went way above the call of duty so many times. Our buyer was to say the least
difficult, yet you handled him with courtesy and respect, while still remembering who your clients were.

Thank you for a job well done. We will be sure to recommend you to all our friends, and anyone else who might mention buying or selling their home.

—Nancy and Mark


I originally did not intend to buy any real estate. After meeting with my accountant, I decided to do a 1031 tax exchange. I called Angie to ask what she knew about this IRS tax deferred program. The next day we met and she explained all the details involved and was a wealth of information. We had a six-week time limit to identify 3 properties I would purchase. Properties were located; offers were made, countered and accepted. I believe this is when Angie’s work really began. She was superb at organizing appointments with home inspectors, property appraisers, escrow officers and mortgage lenders. She is very competent, honest and fun to be around. She has the know how to get the job done and the follow through to take care of all the necessary details. Anyone choosing Angie McMahon as his or her Realtor will be making a wise decision.



As a career military family we have moved and bought and sold homes many times. We would say our experience with Angie McMahon was one of the best! She was an expert at establishing the price of our home. We went over comps together and then actually visited the homes we had been going over so we could compare them ourselves. This helped immensely! She tactfully led us to a realistic price while enabling us to sell the home in a reasonable time. Also important to us was the fact that he is so enjoyable to work with. Selling a home is a very stressful situation, and Angie always was calm and easy to work with. In addition she sold our daughter’s home with the same positive manner. When we move back to Tucson I will definitely call Angie to help us find a home!

—John & LaVonne


Angie was great to work with. Our house sold in 8 days after years of trying to sell previously without Angie. She is very professional, kind, and prompt with everything. I would highly recommend her to either sell or buy.

—Susan Wixon


I just wanted to drop you a note about what an excellent job you did for Karen and I at selling our home. I especially like the way you worked with us on getting professional photographs of our home, and getting us to the right selling price. We were so excited when we got two offers in the first few weeks after listing our home! Since we were living out of the state while selling our home, good communication was
important and yours was outstanding.
Thanks for all your help,

—Bill and Karen


I just recently sold my home and I want to commend Angie McMahon who really came through for me. I had such a horrible experience prior to her coming on board. Angie was tenacious, truthful, and so kind. She really worked hard for me. So I just wanted you to know about her ability and trustworthiness amidst these crazy market times.



Angie is a top notch professional. When looking for an agent, wether you are selling or buying, call Angie McMahon FIRST.

—Vikki Messana-Hunt (Show Low, AZ)


Angie was truly helpful and attentive to our needs. As we were very particular in our search, she was patient until we found our property.

—Ricardo G. (San Francisco, CA)


Angie went over and above expectations. She is a great communicator and terrific on follow-thru. We would definitely use her services again and would recommend anyone looking for property in the Pinetop/Lakeside/Show Low area to contact her.

—Joan N. (Tucson, AZ)


Angie is AMAZING! She found the perfect home for me and my children in 2000. 

She made the process and took on extra work to make this happen and provided constant support all the way through closing. She was not only my realtor but has become a very dear friend. 
Angie has experience selling everything from land and custom homes to luxury condominiums at La Ventana Canyon Resort. 

Angie has experience with all types of financing and can easily guide you through the process. She has the patience of a saint and the knowledge of Encyclopedia Britannica. 

If you want an honest, smart, and easy to work with real estate agent, contact Angie. I cannot give a higher recommendation to her. She brings big city experience to a country setting. She is absolutely fantastic at what she does.

—Kathryn Forgach (Bought a Single Family home in 2000 in Casas Adobes, Tucson, AZ)


Our experience with Angie in the sale of our home was nothing short of excellent! 
Communication was straightforward and to the point. 
Commitments were completed in a timely fashion. 
There were no unpleasant surprises. 
Angie represented us as a professional... never let us down.

—al0h (Sold a Single Family home in 2018 in Show Low, AZ.)


Angie is a true real estate professional with a great personality and attention to detail. Highly recommend.

—Linda V. - Farmhouse Meadows, Gilbert, AZ


Beautiful homes, fast responses, and easy to work with! 5 stars from over here

—Matt C. - Pinetop-Lakeside, AZ